< Previous: Poetry Sunday: The Snowstorm Up: Site Index Next: Open Thread: The Internet Infidels Situation >
The Witch Children of Nigeria

I've written on several past occasions about how belief in malignant supernatural forces causes real harm to real people. There are examples of this from every region of the world, but some of the most wrenching are from Africa, where Biblical beliefs about demons and evil spirits still run rampant.

In January, I wrote about the witch camps of Ghana, where people suspected of using black magic to harm their neighbors are exiled as if they were lepers. In April, there were the Pentecostals of the Congo, who seek to cure mental illness by chaining sufferers to their beds and beating them to drive the demons out. Now, via the Guardian, there's a story out of Nigeria that is far more heart-breaking and horrible than either of those.

Driving through the town of Esit Eket, the rust-streaked signs, tarpaulins hung between trees and posters on boulders, advertise a church for every third or fourth house along the road. Such names as New Testament Assembly, Church of God Mission, Mount Zion Gospel, Glory of God, Brotherhood of the Cross, Redeemed, Apostalistic. Behind the smartly painted doors pastors make a living by 'deliverances' - exorcisms - for people beset by witchcraft, something seen to cause anything from divorce, disease, accidents or job losses. With so many churches it's a competitive market, but by local standards a lucrative one.

If this were merely a case of parasitic clergy making money by preying on superstitious people, exploiting the poor by charging exorbitant sums to chase away imaginary dangers, that would be bad enough. But this atmosphere of fanaticism has taken a far uglier turn.

But an exploitative situation has now grown into something much more sinister as preachers are turning their attentions to children - naming them as witches. In a maddened state of terror, parents and whole villages turn on the child. They are burnt, poisoned, slashed, chained to trees, buried alive or simply beaten and chased off into the bush.

This bold statement would be unbelievable if the story itself didn't provide so many first-hand examples. There are numerous children quoted whose own parents, inflamed to frenzy by Christian preachers, have thrown boiling water and acid at them, who have left them tied to trees for days, who have forced them to drink poison. The children who are not killed by this torture are invariably driven out of their homes to live as homeless orphans in communities that despise and fear them and often attempt to kill them on sight.

As the Guardian article notes prominently, the fervent Christian beliefs of these communities have created the problem, not mitigated it. As with the similar cases from Ghana and the Congo, the spread of fanatic Pentecostal and evangelical sects who interpret the Bible's verses about witches and exorcisms literally have given rise to this outrage.

...it is American and Scottish Pentecostal and evangelical missionaries of the past 50 years who have shaped these fanatical beliefs. Evil spirits, satanic possessions and miracles can be found aplenty in the Bible, references to killing witches turn up in Exodus, Deuteronomy and Galatians, and literal interpretation of scriptures is a popular crowd-pleaser.

And the local preachers who are enriching themselves by shattering families and killing children are not in the least bit apologetic:

Pastor Joe Ita is the preacher at Liberty Gospel Church in nearby Eket. 'We base our faith on the Bible, we are led by the holy spirit and we have a programme of exposing false religion and sorcery.' Soft of voice and in his smart suit and tie, his church is being painted and he apologises for having to sit outside near his shiny new Audi to talk.

...'To give more than you can afford is blessed. We are the only ones who really know the secrets of witches. Parents don't come here with the intention of abandoning their children, but when a child is a witch then you have to say "what is that there? Not your child."

This is a dramatic illustration of the "megaphone" hypothesis of religion amplifying both the good and the bad in human nature in equal measure. At one extreme, it can produce astounding acts of courage and self-sacrificing love. At the other extreme, it can produce hatred, xenophobia and superstitious fear so poisonous that parents can be turned against their own minor children. The flip side of charity and love toward those declared to be in the religious in-group is this savage treatment toward those declared to be in the out-group, and religion is all too effective at placing people outside that charmed circle, declaring them to be less than human.

The hatred and horror visited on these children by their faithful parents underscores the immorality of believing in a book like the Bible that contains such evil superstitions. Even if enlightened believers understand the verses about devils and witches for the savage and primitive falsehoods they are, so long as we promote this book as the word of God, those verses will always be there to be rediscovered by fanatics, with the results we have seen.

This tragic story is one more example of why atheists must work to spread reason and oppose faith in all its guises. Until the day when we can empty the haunted air and banish these pernicious beliefs once and for all, human beings will continue to suffer from the irrational ideologies that teach us to view others as agents of Satan and therefore undeserving of moral consideration.

December 17, 2007, 8:38 am • Posted in: The RotundaCommentOptions

Bookmark This:   Del.icio.us del.icio.us   Digg Digg   Reddit Reddit   StumbleUpon StumbleUpon  

24 Comments

I read the Guardian article and watched the accompanying video last week. This story is beyond horrifying and heartbreaking. I wanted to write about it, but couldn't find a place to start.

Christians in the west claim that their religion is very different from Islam, that the horrors inflicted by Islamic extremists would never be perpetrated by Christians. As for its own bloodstained history, Christians contend that they've outgrown such excesses as inquisitions. This story contradicts that claim and illustrates perfectly why religion in all its forms, liberal --> moderate --> conservative --> extreme, needs to die. Unfortunately, many western Christians will say things like, "Well, this stuff in happening in Africa. Those people are all backwards. They're not real Christians like us and we'd never do that sort of thing." Sorry, I don't buy it.

I am stunned by Pastor Ita's claim:

we have a programme of exposing false religion and sorcery

What I want to say to Pastor Ita is something like, "Excuse me, sir, firstly, all religion is false! Secondly, there is no such thing as sorcery, except in the dark recesses of your seriously troubled mind!"

This stuff is beyond sickening.

They're not real Christians like us and we'd never do that sort of thing.

I wish that I could say 'this would never happen in America', but it does on a regular basis.

BTW see this short story
http://mike-combs.com/writings/condemnd.htm

"Religion amplifies good as well as evil"
only because it acknowledges evil and good. If there are no evils, no one is evil. To say that only those that acknowledge evil are evil is the ultimate opium.

These nutcases are like the 21st century equivalent to the Flaggellants!

"Religion amplifies good as well as evil"
only because it acknowledges evil and good. If there are no evils, no one is evil. To say that only those that acknowledge evil are evil is the ultimate opium.

1) Are you so immoral as to actually contend that the treatment of children described here is not evil?
2) Are you so ignorant that you are actually under the impression that atheists do not acknowledge the existence and importance of morality?

And, I'm wondering how we've gone 5 comments without someone showing up with mealy-mouthed platitudes about how the people don't really believe in Christianity, they're just using it as an excuse to do things they would anyway, etc.

I regret to admit that this kind of story fills me with a black desire to visit the same kind of treatment on the religious maniacs responsible for initiating this child abuse. Maybe a dose of paralysing poison from a certain pufferfish and then set the parishioners to "purifying" their "demon-infested" bodies.

Fortunately I know that I wouldn't do that in reality. I do hope though that, if I were on the ground there in Nigeria, I would find a way to work against these vile and murderous practices.

Oh, forgot "Are your priorities so screwed up that you care more about scoring points off of atheists than about denouncing this form of child abuse?" Unfortunately, that seems to be a given with a sizable proportion of religious "moderates" as well as extremists. :/

As the Guardian article notes prominently, the fervent Christian beliefs of these communities have created the problem, not mitigated it. As with the similar cases from Ghana and the Congo, the spread of fanatic Pentecostal and evangelical sects who interpret the Bible's verses about witches and exorcisms literally have given rise to this outrage.

Do we know anything about what beliefs West and Central Africans had before the missionaries arrived? Were legends about witches, sorcerers, etc. already present? Were punishments, lethal or otherwise, prescribed for them? It may be that the Christians there built on pre-existing traditions, rather than introducing their own. (Although it's torture in either case, obviously.)

There are lots of traditional African beliefs about sorcery, including the common belief that sickness and death are caused by malicious sorcery. A belief that many Africans maintained despite also recognizing other causes of death like hunting elephants and collapsing granaries. So if someone goes out hunting elephants and gets killed by one, it's because someone cast a spell of "Sic 'em" on that elephant. I'm doing this from memory; I don't know of any good sources on "primitive" peoples' beliefs about sorcery.

But those fundie missionaries have clearly made it worse, by demanding huge fees and making people willing to suspect their children. And not doing anything to debunk sorcery, like challenging people to cast spells on them.

I wonder if anyone is doing anything to oppose them, like trying to bring them to justice for fraud.

Another way of looking at this is from the view of the opportunists who pretend they can get rid of demons and witches. In a climate where the people actually believe in such nonsense, those that say they have the power to expel the witches are actually inoculating themselves from being turned on by the populace. Who's going to claim the priest is also a witch?

It's particularly sick that children are being targeted. They have less power to defend themselves. If adults were in more danger, maybe they'd be more likely to feel how silly the accusations of witchcraft are. As it is, the priests have the double safeguard of adulthood and their position.

It may be that the Christians there built on pre-existing traditions, rather than introducing their own. (Although it's torture in either case, obviously.)

Point and counterpoint in one, thank you! I love being able to cite good comments like yours. This was exactly my thought, the latter part, that it's torture regardless, when I read the piece about these not being pre-existing problems.

Does it REALLY matter if these are pre-existing problems or not? Was it not the mission of these churches to get rid of beliefs they found abhorrent and evil? It most certainly was, and if their religion had done nothing to fix pre-existing flaws, it would be reason enough to toss it out.

Instead, it has either exacerbated these problems or invented them entirely. It has turned nations, towns, and even families against themselves. It has stirred up immeasurable cruelty and innumerable horrific acts of fear, violence, and boundless hate.

Africa is ultimately our birthplace as a species, and it's disgusting that the place we have longest been is the place we have longest continued to suffer at our own hands.

Theists like to liken dismissing religion because of its evil acts to throwing the baby out with the bath water, as though such an analogy made sense. For all the good religious people have done, they have done far more bad. No amount of aid from the Christian Children's Fund could ever justify the Crusades, let alone the monstrosity that has sprung up in Africa.

Casting out religion would be more akin to sacrificing a few healthy cells to remove a cancerous tumor.

__
One cannot but weep, staring wide-eyed into the night sky, thinking of all the interactions that eventually brought us to be, from the big bang to the solar forges to Earth's formation to the first sparks of life, all the way to the present day... It's an amazing and wonderful thing.

But turning one's eyes upon humanity, one cannot but weep for an altogether different reason.

An additional point is that most of the good things done by religious people are done out of a sense of compassion for their fellow humans - for human reasons. While most of the evil things done by religious people are also done for human reasons (greed, anger, revenge, etc.), there is a huge subset of evil things that are done for reasons that are absolutely religious and thus are unique to religions (and a few ideologies that are religions in all but name, like Communism). While theists habitually cry foul when this is pointed out, the fact is that with or without religion good people will do good things and evil people will do evil things. Religion, and a few ideologies that are almost identical in practice, are the only known ways of making good people do evil things.

Soft of voice and in his smart suit and tie, his church is being painted and he apologises for having to sit outside near his shiny new Audi to talk.

...'To give more than you can afford is blessed.

[emphasis mine]
Perfect juxtaposition of quotes.

It has turned nations, towns, and even families against themselves.

Well, Jesus does make a big show out of how one should forsake one's family for god.

An additional point is that most of the good things done by religious people are done out of a sense of compassion for their fellow humans - for human reasons.

I would argue that probably quite a few religious people do good things simply because they want to go to heaven.

So, the witch hunts are still alive and well after all... When are we going to learn to leave this kind of shit in the Dark Ages (where it belongs)?

Not just Nigeria. Apparently it's an export business.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2089-2025330,00.html
Quite chilling that this goes on today.

I love being able to cite good comments like yours.

Aw shucks, etc.

Religion, and a few ideologies that are almost identical in practice, are the only known ways of making good people do evil things.

Alex, are you channeling somebody here? Better be careful, or we'll have to exorcise you. BOOGA BOOGA FIRE.

A belief that many Africans maintained despite also recognizing other causes of death like hunting elephants and collapsing granaries. So if someone goes out hunting elephants and gets killed by one, it's because someone cast a spell of "Sic 'em" on that elephant.

I think it's most accurate to say that there's an unfortunate correspondence: the traditional religions, many of which are in decline, accustomed people to the idea of believing in sorcery and sympathetic magic. This paved the way for the far more virulent Christian traditions, now on the rise, which exploit those beliefs to enrich their preachers and are now destroying families and communities.

Of course, I'm sure these witch-hunting Christians, if asked, would fiercely deny that their beliefs have pagan antecedents (and, in fairness, one could reinvent these ideas entirely from the Bible without any reference to traditional religions). Whatever the historical influence exerted by the older belief systems, it seems clear that, in this case, Christianity is both the proximate and dominant cause.

I found an interesting short article on witch smelling, a traditional ceremony for hunting down whoever had allegedly caused some misfortune with sorcery.

So those fundies are most likely building on pre-existing beliefs about the efficacy of sorcery, rather than trying to debunk such beliefs by challenging people to put hexes on them.

In any case, belief in the efficacy of sorcery is a widespread and cross-cultural belief, making one wonder what induces belief in that. I wonder if Daniel Dennett has addressed that question in his work on what makes people believe in religions; it seems like a closely-related one.

And extending the arguments of certain religious apologists, if we refuse to believe in the efficacy of sorcery and refuse to cringe in fear of malicious sorcery, we will not be very happy or mentally healthy, and we will become miserable and depressed.

And as Richard Carrier has noted in his master's thesis, Cultural History of the Lunar and Solar Eclipse in the Early Roman Empire, many less-educated Romans believed that lunar eclipses were caused by sorcerers making the Moon go away, and they would often make a lot of noise to try to interfere with those sorcerers' efforts. Plutarch noted that education was good for women as for men, because someone who's educated would refuse to take seriously anyone who claimed the ability to cause a lunar eclipse. Plutarch also claimed that some centuries earlier, a certain Aglaonike had used her ability to predict lunar eclipses to convince people that she could cause them.

And nearly 15 centuries later, Christopher Columbus would do just that to some pesky Native Americans to get them to help him and his crew.

I am a Christian. I am horrified by this. The problem as Im seeing it is actually a lot larger and more insidious. There are swelling groups of christians determined to bring in a worldwide "christendom". They are known as "kingdom now", "theonomists", "reconstructionists". They are separate groups working tward the same goals. google these terms and you'll see what I mean. This may well be part of that.

Sign the petition

http://www.thepetitionsite.com/2/children-are-targets-of-nigerian-witch-hunt

This needs to stop!

Africa have been in fact coerce into white Catholic Christian method of dealing with mental condition ; from the bribed with food in trade for their culture and god. Performing exorcisms to deal with mental disorders of the people of Africa, is only going to enhance the mental disorder into an stage of non- rehablitaton, that can turns into a major mental disease. These people, if they are suffering from in psychological disorder; should get psychiatric treatment for the condition. More clinics needs to be established.
Also, the person with illness, may be a resistant member; and the church is actually in sect; that is trying to retrieve the ex- member. Those thing should be observed . You should follow a process of examining, in person that is acting in an dumb nature.

1) First, see if the person have any religious belief .
2 )Second, if they do find out if the religion is safe and haven’t pressured them in anyway .
3)Third , if they were not pressured , maybe they need mental health treatment
4 )Fourth, if they were pressured , the right authority may need to notified; so they can expose the cult/sect .

I myself was victimized by in cult ; which is Refuge Church of Christ , that is overseen by Bishop Bonner; his body is all over the United States and an Africa. They have destroyed my family life tremendously . They prompted adoption of resistant ex - members

Please make sure that, churches are monitored when the began to sprout in your country.

Take care Africa my descendant land of beauty and the originators.

"This tragic story is one more example of why atheists must work to spread reason and oppose faith in all its guises."

You sound just as fanatical as fanatical Christians and Muslims wishing to spread their beliefs.

Leave a comment

This comment form is a trap for spambots. If you can see it, don't use it. Use the comment form below.

Please uncheck this box before submitting your comment

Do not uncheck this box

Please uncheck this box before submitting your comment

Do not uncheck this box

Please note: First-time commenters are subject to moderation.

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Comment preview:

Other options:

RECENT POSTS

MUST-READ POSTS (view all)

RECENT COMMENTS

SITE CATEGORIES (explanation)

ARCHIVES

BLOGROLL

PODCASTS

OTHER LINKS

THIS BLOG'S PARENT SITE

SEARCH THIS SITE

WHAT I'M READING

The Ancestor's Tale by Richard Dawkins

past books >

The Humanist Symposium
The Out Campaign

RSS 2.0 FEED

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

WHY "DAYLIGHT ATHEISM"?

FEEDBACK

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional Opera
Firefox

Powered by WordPress